What's inside the newsletter from L.L.Bean
- Sender
- llbean@e2.global.llbean.com
- Sending platform
- Salesforce Marketing Cloud
- Sector
- Sports & outdoor
- Emails read
- 12 campaigns, 1 transactional
- Period
- November 2026
Our address received its first email in November 2026, after the CNIL recommendation was published (April 14, 2026).
Overall scoreThe main finding
An open-tracking pixel is present on the last 3 campaigns.
It is the first of 9 points to fix. The highest score is deliverability (100/100), the lowest compliance (60/100), better than 90% of the 640 brands measured.
One email when a criterion changes state: the Pro version, in early access.
Share
Share this report
November 2026 · calculated on 22 November
9 points to fix
Each line leads to the criterion in its family, with the excerpt that establishes it and how to fix it.
-
Priority
An open-tracking pixel is present
Criterion “No open-tracking pixel”
Compliance
on the last 3 campaigns
−30 pts
out of 30 in
Compliance
<img src="https://click.e2.global.llbean.com/open.aspx?qs=***&d=***&bmt…
Salesforce Marketing Cloud: tracking is on by default for Email Studio sends and is set at the “send definition” level.
-
Priority
Layout tables nested beyond the threshold
Criterion “A shallow template”
Technical
measured on 12 campaigns
−20 pts
out of 20 in
Technical
Flatten the template: one content block per table, placed directly in the main column, with no wrapper table around each section.
-
To review
Some links become invisible when images are blocked
Criterion “All links stay visible with images blocked”
Experience
on all 12 campaigns
−15 pts
out of 15 in
Experience
Every important action (main button, unsubscribe) exists as text or as an HTML button, not only as a clickable image.
- To review The message puts obstacles in the way of assistive technology Criterion “The message stays readable with assistive technology” Experience measured on 12 campaigns −10 pts out of 20 in Experience
- To review Some links lead nowhere Criterion “Every link leads somewhere” Technical on all 12 campaigns −10 pts out of 10 in Technical
- To review No separate path to refuse tracking Criterion “The recipient keeps control over tracking” Compliance measured on 12 campaigns −10 pts out of 20 in Compliance
- To review Some tap targets are too small for a finger Criterion “Tap targets large enough” Experience on all 12 campaigns −10 pts out of 10 in Experience
- Secondary The HTML exceeds Gmail's clipping threshold Criterion “HTML under Gmail's clipping threshold” Technical on 2 of the 12 campaigns −4.2 pts out of 25 in Technical
- Secondary The message reads poorly without its images or does not announce itself in the inbox Criterion “The message makes sense without its images, from the inbox on” Experience measured on 12 campaigns −2.1 pts out of 25 in Experience
15 criteria met, including « Unsubscribing is possible and announced » and « DKIM signature validated ». They are listed in their family, below.
Every send, at the time it arrived
One dot per message received by our subscription since November. Tap a dot to open it; the arrows move from one send to the next.
Technical reading of the send of Nov. 21, 2026 →
- campaigns in 2 weeks
- 12
- about 6 a week, in November
- every day of the week
- 7 days a week
- 1 to 3 campaigns depending on the day
- favourite sending hour
- 8 h
- 83% of campaigns arrive between 8:00 and 9:00
- last send received
- 21 Nov.
- « Your Favorite L.L.Bean Flannel, Now 20% OFF »
Campaign 1 of 12
Wednesday 4 Nov., 19:05
Great Products Have Great Stories
- Type
- Marketing campaign
- Score
- 74 / 100
- Pixel
- Present, detected by the form of its address
Campaign 2 of 12
Thursday 5 Nov., 8:31
Our 1933 Chamois in New Archival Prints
- Type
- Marketing campaign
- Score
- 67 / 100
- Pixel
- Present, detected by the form of its address
Campaign 3 of 12
Sunday 8 Nov., 8:31
The Corduroy Pants for Absolutely Anywhere
- Type
- Marketing campaign
- Score
- 74 / 100
- Pixel
- Present, detected by the form of its address
Campaign 4 of 12
Tuesday 10 Nov., 8:31
Gift Idea: Our Softest Flannel PJs
- Type
- Marketing campaign
- Score
- 69 / 100
- Pixel
- Present, detected by the form of its address
Campaign 5 of 12
Friday 13 Nov., 8:31
15% OFF Your Purchase + UP TO 50% OFF Sale Styles
- Type
- Marketing campaign
- Score
- 74 / 100
- Pixel
- Present, detected by the form of its address
Campaign 6 of 12
Saturday 14 Nov., 8:31
Cozy, Giftable & 15% OFF (Plus, Up to 50% OFF Sale Styles!)
- Type
- Marketing campaign
- Score
- 74 / 100
- Pixel
- Present, detected by the form of its address
Campaign 7 of 12
Sunday 15 Nov., 8:31
Use Promo Code: GLOBAL15
- Type
- Marketing campaign
- Score
- 74 / 100
- Pixel
- Present, detected by the form of its address
Campaign 8 of 12
Monday 16 Nov., 8:31
Ends Tomorrow! 15% OFF Your Purchase + Up to 50% OFF Sale Styles
- Type
- Marketing campaign
- Score
- 71 / 100
- Pixel
- Present, detected by the form of its address
Campaign 9 of 12
Tuesday 17 Nov., 8:31
Ends Tonight! 15% OFF Your Purchase + UP TO 50% OFF Sale Styles
- Type
- Marketing campaign
- Score
- 74 / 100
- Pixel
- Present, detected by the form of its address
Campaign 10 of 12
Tuesday 17 Nov., 17:31
Last Chance: 15% OFF Your Purchase + Up to 50% OFF Sale Styles
- Type
- Marketing campaign
- Score
- 74 / 100
- Pixel
- Present, detected by the form of its address
Campaign 11 of 12
Thursday 19 Nov., 8:31
20% OFF L.L.Bean Flannel? Yes, Please.
- Type
- Marketing campaign
- Score
- 74 / 100
- Pixel
- Present, detected by the form of its address
Campaign 12 of 12
Saturday 21 Nov., 8:31
Your Favorite L.L.Bean Flannel, Now 20% OFF
- Type
- Marketing campaign
- Score
- 74 / 100
- Pixel
- Present, detected by the form of its address
Sending day
- Mon.
- Tue.
- Wed.
- Thu.
- Fri.
- Sat.
- Sun.
Arrival time
No change observed since November
Each campaign is compared with the previous one, criterion by criterion.
Criteria in detail
The 24 criteria + 1 bonus
Compliance
These checks cover what the send imposes on the recipient and what it leaves them: measurement of their behaviour, ways to leave, tracking of their objection.
The calculation · 60 pts out of 100
4 met · 1 partly met · 1 not met
Weight of each criterion in the score.
No open-tracking pixel Not met Open-tracking pixel detected on the last 3 campaigns 0/30 pts
0 points out of 30 — met on 0 of the last 3 campaigns.
An invisible image tells the sending platform that the message was opened, when, and from which device: this is individual tracking of reading behavior, and the recipient sees none of it. The message does not say whether they consented or objected — that choice lives in the sending platform, not in the email.
Served from llbean.com.
The excerpt that establishes it
<img src="https://click.e2.global.llbean.com/open.aspx?qs=***&d=***&bmt=***" width="1" height="1" alt="">
How to fix it
Salesforce Marketing Cloud: tracking is on by default for Email Studio sends and is set at the “send definition” level. An email sent through the API can carry a different setting from the one in the interface.
Specific to salesforce-mc — not yet re-opened in the tool
Met when no tracking pixel is present. A single pixel is enough for the criterion not to be met on an email.
- CNIL 14/04/2026 · LIL art. 82
- PM-PRIV-001
- The detection rule
Unsubscribing is possible and announced Met Unsubscribing is announced, in the header and in the body on 12 campaigns 15 pts
15 points out of 15 — share of observations met across 12 campaigns.
Met when the message announces unsubscribing in its headers, through a page rather than an email to write, and in its body. The detail says which of the two is missing. Not applicable to a transactional email.
What was measured — 2 met out of 2
- Unsubscribe announced in the header, through a page on 12 campaigns Met
- Unsubscribe link in the body on 12 campaigns Met
- RFC 2369
- PM-PRIV-002
- RFC 2369 — The Use of URLs as Meta-Syntax for Core Mail List Commands
The recipient keeps control over tracking Partly met No separate path to refuse tracking on the 12 campaigns concerned (1 of 2 measures met) 10/20 pts
10 points out of 20 — share of observations met across 12 campaigns.
How to fix it
A path separate from the unsubscribe link leads to a preference centre where the recipient can refuse tracking (opens, clicks) without unsubscribing. Most email platforms offer this page; otherwise it goes in the template footer, with its own link, named for what it does (“manage my preferences”, “refuse tracking”).
The page takes an afternoon to set up and then serves every send. It is what the CNIL recommendation expects from an email that measures how its readers behave.
Two measures: does the unsubscribe link go through a tracker, and does a separate path lead to a preference center or to refusing tracking? Neither establishes that a refusal succeeds — checking would require following the link, which would record a click on the sending platform's side. They describe the control left to the recipient, not the result they would get.
What was measured — 1 met out of 2
- Untracked unsubscribe link on 12 campaigns Met
- No separate path to refuse tracking on the 12 campaigns concerned Not met
- CNIL 14/04/2026 · Postmetry
- PM-PRIV-003
The message says who is writing and under which rules Met The message says who is writing and under which rules on 12 campaigns 15 pts
15 points out of 15 — share of observations met across 12 campaigns.
A commercial email must make it possible to identify the advertiser (CPCE, article L. 34-5), and the recipient must be able to know who processes their data. This indicator groups what a message can show of it.
What was measured — 3 met out of 3
- The message names its sender on 12 campaigns Met
- A reply to the message is possible on 12 campaigns Met
- A link leads to the privacy policy on 12 campaigns Met
- CPCE L. 34-5 · directive 2000/31 art. 6 · CAN-SPAM
- PM-PRIV-004
An untracked path leads to the site Met An untracked path leads to the site on 12 campaigns 10 pts
10 points out of 10 — met on 12 of 12 campaigns concerned.
Met when at least one link in the message leads to the brand's site without going through a click counter.
- Postmetry
- PM-PRIV-005
No recipient identifier in the message Met No recipient identifier in the message on 12 campaigns 10 pts
10 points out of 10 — met on 12 of 12 campaigns concerned.
Met when the recipient's address appears — neither in clear, nor encoded, nor hashed — in no URL and no proprietary header. Addressing headers do not count: they carry it by design.
- Postmetry · RGPD art. 4 en repère
- PM-PRIV-020
Deliverability
These checks read the authentication verdict set by our server when the message arrived. This verdict is dated by construction: we never recalculate it, which would query today's DNS rather than the DNS of the day the email was sent.
The calculation · 85 pts out of 85, scaled to 100
6 met
Weight of each criterion in the score.
DKIM signature validated Met Valid DKIM signature on 12 campaigns 20 pts
20 points out of 20 — met on 12 of 12 campaigns concerned.
Met when our receiving server validated the DKIM signature of the email.
- RFC 6376 · RFC 8601
- PM-DELIV-001
- RFC 6376 — DomainKeys Identified Mail (DKIM) Signatures
- RFC 8601 — Message Header Field for Indicating Message Authentication Status
DMARC alignment validated Met DMARC alignment verified on 12 campaigns 20 pts
20 points out of 20 — met on 12 of 12 campaigns concerned.
Met when the domain shown in the sender matches the one that authenticated the message.
- RFC 9989
- PM-DELIV-002
- RFC 9989 — Domain-Based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance (DMARC)
DMARC policy that helps keep out some impersonation Met Active DMARC policy on 12 campaigns 15 pts
15 points out of 15 — met on 12 of 12 campaigns concerned.
Met when the published policy is “reject” or “quarantine”. A “none” policy asks nothing of mail providers: it is published with no effect on messages that impersonate the domain.
- RFC 9989 §4.7
- PM-DELIV-003
- RFC 9989 — section 4.7, “p” tag
No SPF failure Met No SPF failure on 12 campaigns 10 pts
10 points out of 10 — met on 12 of 12 campaigns concerned.
Met when SPF does not fail. An SPF “none” alongside a valid DKIM and DMARC is a common and legitimate configuration: it is not penalized.
- RFC 7208
- PM-DELIV-004
- RFC 7208 — Sender Policy Framework (SPF) for Authorizing Use of Domains in Email
One-click unsubscribe, as defined by RFC 8058 Met One-click unsubscribe as defined by RFC 8058 on 12 campaigns 15 pts
15 points out of 15 — share of observations met across 12 campaigns.
Met when the “List-Unsubscribe” header carries an https address and “List-Unsubscribe-Post” is exactly “List-Unsubscribe=One-Click”. This is what Gmail and Yahoo require of bulk senders: the mailbox's button then acts without opening a page. Not applicable to a transactional email.
What was measured — 2 met out of 2
- The unsubscribe header carries an https address on 12 campaigns Met
- One-click unsubscribe announced on 12 campaigns Met
- RFC 8058 · Gmail et Yahoo
- PM-DELIV-005
A DKIM signature that covers what matters Met The DKIM signature covers what matters in the message on 12 campaigns 5 pts
5 points out of 5 — share of observations met across 12 campaigns.
What the signature covers, not only that it passes: an algorithm accepted by RFC 8301, the whole body signed, the From, Subject, Date and List-Unsubscribe headers signed, a signature not expired on receipt. Not applicable without a DKIM signature.
What was measured — 3 met out of 3
- Accepted signing algorithm on 12 campaigns Met
- Whole body signed on 12 campaigns Met
- Essential headers signed on 12 campaigns Met
- Signature valid on receipt Not applicable
- RFC 6376 · RFC 8301
- PM-DELIV-006
Technical
These checks cover what email clients actually do with the message: truncation, style blocks removed, resources never loaded. Each threshold states where it comes from: the documented behaviour of an email client, a specification, or our own method.
The calculation · 51 pts out of 85, scaled to 100
3 met · 1 partly met · 2 not met
Weight of each criterion in the score.
HTML under Gmail's clipping threshold Partly met HTML over Gmail's clipping threshold (2 of 12 campaigns concerned) 20.8/25 pts
20.8 points out of 25 — met on 10 of 12 campaigns concerned.
How to fix it
Weight comes down by removing unused CSS, deleting duplicated hidden blocks (mobile and desktop versions of the same content), removing comments and Outlook conditional code that is no longer needed, and embedding no base64 images. Most editors show the HTML weight before sending.
Above 102 KB, Gmail clips the message and shows “View entire message”: the footer, the legal notices and the unsubscribe link drop out of the first read.
Met when the HTML part stays under 102 KB. Beyond that, Gmail cuts off the end of the message — and the end is where the unsubscribe link and the notices are.
- Gmail
- PM-TECH-001
A shallow template Not met Layout tables nested beyond the threshold on the 12 campaigns concerned (0 of 1 measures met) 0/20 pts
0 points out of 20 — share of observations met across 12 campaigns.
How to fix it
Flatten the template: one content block per table, placed directly in the main column, with no wrapper table around each section.
In a block-based editor, nesting usually comes from a section placed inside another, or a column inside a column. It is fixed once, in the template, not campaign by campaign.
The technical reading of the email gives the measured nesting and its threshold: it tells you when the fix has taken effect.
Met when layout tables are nested no more than 6 levels deep. Beyond that, the Word engine shared by desktop Outlook and the diverging clients each render the template their own way.
What was measured — 0 met out of 1
- Layout tables nested beyond the threshold on the 12 campaigns concerned Not met
- Postmetry
- PM-TECH-002
Well-formed HTML Met Well-formed HTML on 12 campaigns 15 pts
15 points out of 15 — share of observations met across 12 campaigns.
A doctype, a character set declared in the document, balanced tags and unique identifiers. Each client repairs incomplete markup its own way, which is what makes rendering unpredictable. End tags that HTML makes optional do not count.
What was measured — 4 met out of 4
- Doctype declared on 12 campaigns Met
- Character set declared in the HTML on 12 campaigns Met
- Balanced tags on 12 campaigns Met
- Unique identifiers on 12 campaigns Met
- WHATWG
- PM-TECH-030
Every link leads somewhere Not met Some links lead nowhere on the 12 campaigns concerned 0/10 pts
0 points out of 10 — met on 0 of 12 campaigns concerned.
How to fix it
Every link has an absolute https target; no href="#", no href="", no relative link and no mailto: without an address. Empty links most often come from a block copied from an earlier template, or from a button whose URL was never filled in in the editor.
An empty link loses the click and signals a message put together in a hurry; the fix is a review of the link list before sending, which most editors offer.
Met when no link is empty, reduced to “#” or written as “javascript:”. Such a link leads nowhere, and most clients neutralise it. Not applicable if the message contains no link.
- Postmetry
- PM-TECH-031
No remote stylesheet Met No remote stylesheet on 12 campaigns 10 pts
10 points out of 10 — met on 12 of 12 campaigns concerned.
Met when the message calls no external stylesheet, through “link” or “@import”. Several clients never load them. A font stylesheet does not count: without it, the text falls back to another font.
- caniemail
- PM-TECH-020
- <link> in an email — support by client
The message follows the shape of an email Met The message follows the shape of an email on 12 campaigns 5 pts
5 points out of 5 — share of observations met across 12 campaigns.
Lines of 998 bytes at most, readable Message-ID and Date, a character set announced on every text part, a transfer encoding consistent with the content (RFC 5322, RFC 2045). Most servers tolerate these deviations, each in its own way.
What was measured — 5 met out of 5
- Lines of 998 bytes at most on 12 campaigns Met
- Well-formed Message-ID on 12 campaigns Met
- Readable date on 12 campaigns Met
- Character set announced on every text part on 12 campaigns Met
- Consistent transfer encoding on 12 campaigns Met
- RFC 5322 · RFC 2045
- PM-TECH-010
Experience
Four questions about what becomes of the message once received: does it stay understandable, can the recipient still act, can a client render it, can a screen display it. Automatic detection only covers what is declared in the message.
The calculation · 63 pts out of 100
2 met · 2 partly met · 2 not met · 1 bonus
Weight of each criterion in the score.
The message makes sense without its images, from the inbox on Partly met Preheader missing, too short or too long (2 of 12 campaigns concerned) (1 of 2 measures met) 22.9/25 pts
22.9 points out of 25 — share of observations met across 12 campaigns.
How to fix it
A preheader of 40 to 130 characters, in real text, follows the subject in the inbox; every meaningful image has an alt attribute that says what it shows; the main message is in text, not inside an image. In the editor, the preheader is a dedicated field, and the alt is filled in image by image.
Half of readers see the message without images when it first opens. An alt and a preheader take a minute per campaign.
Met when the message keeps at least 200 readable characters with images blocked, and a preheader of 40 to 130 characters announces it in the message list. Without a preheader, the inbox shows the first text of the body instead — often “View in browser”.
What was measured — 1 met out of 2
- At least 200 characters remain readable with images blocked on 12 campaigns Met
- Preheader missing, too short or too long (2 of 12 campaigns concerned) Partly met
- Postmetry
- PM-EXP-001
The message can be rendered outside HTML Met A text version renders the message on 12 campaigns 15 pts
15 points out of 15 — share of observations met across 12 campaigns.
Met when a text version comes with the email and carries the essentials: at least 60% of its text and 80% of its links. A client that does not display HTML falls back on it; reduced to “view the web version”, it renders nothing.
What was measured — 3 met out of 3
- A plain-text version accompanies the message on 12 campaigns Met
- The text version carries at least 60% of the text on 12 campaigns Met
- The text version carries at least 80% of the links on 12 campaigns Met
- Postmetry
- PM-EXP-002
All links stay visible with images blocked Not met Some links become invisible with images blocked on the 12 campaigns concerned 0/15 pts
0 points out of 15 — met on 0 of 12 campaigns concerned.
How to fix it
Every important action (main button, unsubscribe) exists as text or as an HTML button, not only as a clickable image. For an image button, an alt that names the action and a background colour on the cell keep the area visible even without the image.
With images blocked, an image button becomes an empty rectangle: the reader does not know where to click.
Met when no link is carried by a single image without alternative text: such a link leaves nothing on screen. Not applicable if the message contains no links.
- Postmetry
- PM-EXP-003
Tap targets large enough Not met Tap targets under the retained size on the 12 campaigns concerned 0/10 pts
0 points out of 10 — met on 0 of 12 campaigns concerned.
How to fix it
Links and buttons are at least 24 px tall, with space between two neighbouring links; an HTML button (a table cell with background and padding) reaches that size without an image. Small footer links are separated by a line break rather than by a |.
On a phone, a target smaller than a finger gets missed or the tap lands next to it; 24 px is the WCAG 2.2 level AA minimum.
Met when no sized tap target falls below 24 px a side (WCAG 2.2, criterion 2.5.8). Only targets with a declared dimension are measured; the criterion's exceptions — a target within a line of text, sufficient spacing — are not. Not applicable if the message declares no dimensions.
- WCAG 2.2 — 2.5.8
- PM-EXP-004
- WCAG 2.2 — Target Size (Minimum), success criterion 2.5.8, level AA
The message stays readable with assistive technology Partly met The message puts obstacles in the way of assistive technology — 2 of 4 measures met 10/20 pts
10 points out of 20 — share of observations met across 12 campaigns.
How to fix it
Four fixes, all in the template: declare the message language on the <html> tag (lang="en" for an email in English), describe each content image in its alt attribute, mark layout tables with role="presentation", and write links that say where they lead rather than “click here”.
The criterion detail shows which ones are missing from your emails; the others are already met.
A decorative image — divider, spacer — keeps an empty alt="": that is what keeps it silent, not an oversight.
Declared language, described content images, layout tables marked as such, link texts that say where they lead: what a screen reader needs to render the message. The detail says which of these measures is missing.
What was measured — 2 met out of 4
- Message language declared on 12 campaigns Met
- Some content images are not described on the 12 campaigns concerned Not met
- Layout tables announced as data tables on the 12 campaigns concerned Not met
- Every link says where it leads on 12 campaigns Met
The message declares its adaptation to screens Met The message declares its adaptation to screens on 12 campaigns 15 pts
15 points out of 15 — share of observations met across 12 campaigns.
Met when the message declares its viewport and its adaptation to screen width. Without them, it displays on a phone at its original width, and is read by zooming and scrolling sideways.
What was measured — 2 met out of 2
- Viewport declared on 12 campaigns Met
- Adaptation to screen width declared on 12 campaigns Met
- W3C
- PM-EXP-026
- CSS Device Adaptation — the viewport tag
- Media Queries Level 4
Dark mode declared Bonus point not earned The message does not declare its support for dark mode on the 12 campaigns concerned +0 pts
0 points out of 5 — met on 0 of 12 campaigns concerned.
Earned when the message declares color-scheme or a prefers-color-scheme rule. No standard requires it — clients that force dark mode invert the colors themselves — but declaring it leaves control to the template rather than to the mail client.
- caniemail
- PM-EXP-027
Does this address really send L.L.Bean's emails? DKIM d=e2.global.llbean.com · SPF pass · DKIM pass · DMARC pass · 12 campaigns
Across 12 campaigns from L.L.Bean received at our addresses since November 2026:
- From field
- llbean@e2.global.llbean.com · 12 of 12
- DKIM signing domain (d=)
- e2.global.llbean.com · 12 of 12 s12.y.mc.salesforce.com · 12 of 12
- Verdict on receipt
- SPF pass · 12 of 12 DKIM pass · 12 of 12 DMARC pass · 12 of 12
The verdict is the one the receiving server wrote in the Authentication-Results header when the message arrived: it is read, never recomputed.
These findings describe the emails received at our addresses. They say nothing about a message received elsewhere: the From field can be written freely, and only the headers of the message you received show the path it took.
Sector comparison
Sports & outdoor — 45 brands with at least one campaign analyzed. The shares below are counted on them, never on the catalog.
Reading notes
How to read this page
-
A criterion that is not observable or not applicable leaves the calculation. It stays listed, never counted as zero: its weight leaves the denominator rather than weighing as a failure.
-
Each line describes an observable finding, with the excerpt that establishes it. No legal qualification is ever attached to it.
-
The measurements come from deterministic analyzers: the same message always gives the same result, and a disputed finding can be redone identically from the archive.
-
Every share is published on an observed basis, and names it: “26 of 30 brands analyzed.” A brand with no email received enters no denominator.
-
The deliverability score is borrowed: its verdict comes from the server that received the message. All the other families come from our own analyzers.
Does this analysis speak to you?
Let's go through it together, in 20 minutes.
We go over the 9 points with you, the evidence for each and the order in which to fix them. By video call, no commitment.
Or take it with you: the PDF report